
Overview
Serves Rochester, NY
Business hours
SunClosedMon8:00 am - 6:00 pmTue8:00 am - 6:00 pmWed8:00 am - 6:00 pmThu8:00 am - 6:00 pmFri8:00 am - 6:00 pmSat9:00 am - 2:00 pm
Payment methods
This pro accepts payments via Cash, Check, Credit card, and Debit card.
Services offered
Contact
+15857717590
12 Spruce Ln, Rochester, NY 14622
Reviews
4.0
97 reviews
5
4
3
2
1
Joe Gabriel
Sep 13, 2021
•From Google
It is my pleasure to recommend First Choice Renovations. First Choice is a roofing, siding, windows & doors, and now decking company owned by James Edwards.
I am a very particular person (understatement) who is always leery of being taken advantage of during life’s big purchases – cars, roofs, siding, remodeling. I’ve always sought out larger, established companies as one way to minimize risk. I recently hired a large, well-known company to vinyl side a rental property. At the start of the job, I learned the crew onsite was not from the company I hired it was subbed out to First Choice Renovations. Alarms were going off in my head…after all my careful shopping for a reputable contractor…my job got subbed out anyway. That’s when I met James and first heard, “Joe, you have nothing to worry about. I got you. I have a great team; will take care of you; and you will be satisfied.” James shared his company had been vinyl siding homes for four of the largest, well-known companies for a number of years and is beginning to step into the forefront to take jobs directly. The job went great. James shared some ideas that saved me money. During the job, James would call and text updates often. He even called to share that a ladder accidently hit the security light on my garage and broke the bulb. “Just calling to share that it was my team that broke the bulb and they would be picking up a replacement bulb that evening.” The job was done on time and I was very happy.
Based on the first positive experience, I decided to hire First Choice Renovations to vinyl side a second property; but this time hiring them directly. I saved a lot of money as compared to the larger company quotations. James’s “I got you Joe” philosophy was evident from start to finish. Here are a few examples:
Just days before the job was to start, I decided to replace the porch floor myself. My plan was to install Trex flooring before the vinyl siding was installed. When I removed the flooring, it exposed that one section of the porch framing was rotten; put your finger thru it rotten. The feeling I was now over my head came over me in the form of a cold-sweat. I decided to call James as my decisions to remedy might affect his team. He showed up with his foreman, they took a look at my issue and said, “We got you.” They sent me to home depot to buy supplies. They returned to cut out the rotten boards and installed the new framing for me. Because of their experience, it took them no time at all. They were done while I would have still been assessing the problem; my problem; not part of the job I hired them to do. No charge. With the framing squared away, I was able to install the Trex flooring ahead of the job as planned.
After the job was done and James was paid in full, I noticed a couple things that we OK…just not great. I was apprehensive to call because it was a huge job and compared to the overall success of the project…the items were minor. But I did call. James quickly said, “I got you.” and the items were addressed. It went so well, he and I agreed to have his decking guy come rebuild the porch steps and install the vinyl railing. Saving me from doing it.
The house has been transformed and is ready for the next 100 years; just look at the before and after pictures!
First Choice Renovations exceeded my expectations. That is why I so enthusiastically recommend their services. I have every confidence that First Choice Renovations & James Edwards will take care of you too!
Dan
Sep 13, 2023
•From Google
If I could give zero stars, I would. Hired First Choice last October to install new siding, demo and rebuild our porch, and install storm doors in the porch and back of our house. When we first talked to the owner James, he was super nice, extremely flexible on the date to start the project, and my wife and I felt like we were in good hands.
With that said, here's issues that we had with First Choice:
-Did irreparable damage to trees on our property without asking.
-Didn't build the doorway to our porch the correct size so that it matched the storm door we bought ahead of time, per our agreement. When I brought this up to James he blamed my wife and I for buying the wrong size door and wanted us to leave our porch without a door until a new door could be purchased. One of the workers later told me that they never measured the door that was going to be installed and instead just measured the threshold from the old storm door. James was no longer friendly after this.
-Although our storm door was eventually installed, it doesn’t close properly and catches on the bottom corner of the door jamb and we have to pull the door quite hard for it to close. We’ve had several contractors look at the door, all of whom said our only recourse would be to buy a new door, redo the doorway opening, or bend the door jamb.
-Installed a recess around our hose spigot incorrectly, so now my wife and I can’t use our hands to attach and detach our hose and have to use a wrench.
-After reinstalling our windows in our porch, my wife and I couldn't properly close them and we noticed they looked weird-we thought they weren't reinstalled level. When we brought this to James' attention, he claimed there was nothing wrong and the issue was that our windows weren’t meant to be reinstalled, were warped, and wouldn’t even attempt to fix the windows at all. My wife and I then had several separate contractors look at the windows, all of whom said the windows weren't installed square, and that they never heard of windows warping from being taken out and then reinstalled. It was only after I told James that I had other contractors tell us the windows weren’t installed square that First Choice was willing to fix the windows.
-On 3 sides of our house, the siding didn’t come down low enough, and some of the plywood and insulation underneath was visible, along with a sill plate up front. When I brought this up to James, he said this wasn’t an issue. When I wouldn’t drop it, he agreed to install some additional material to cover what was exposed. He did this on only one side of the house. When I reached out to him to ask him to come back to finish what we agreed upon, he never responded to me.
-All of the caulking done to our windows and at various spots on the siding looked incredibly sloppy. When this was brought to Jame’s attention, he said he didn’t think anything was wrong with the caulking. When I continued to bring it up, James agreed to recaulk around the house, which he did, but it still looks awful. Since First Choice finished working on our house, other contractors we’ve had come to fix things First Choice messed up or to work on other things have all mentioned that the caulking done around the porch and siding is super messy and looks terrible.
-Various cuts to J-channel and flashing that look terrible, and, when brought to James’ attention, nothing was done to fix them.
-One other thing, James informed me that his wife paid for fake Google reviews. I know this because I asked him why a lot of the Google reviews seemed oddly fake. He then got flustered at the question and explained that his wife had paid for reviews.
From afar, our siding looks great, but when you start to zero in on specific areas, you notice just how sloppy of a job First Choice did. First Choice gave us the cheapest quote of all the companies we spoke to and now I understand why. We would never, ever use them again, and I’d highly recommend going with a different contractor.
Miguel Vazquez
Sep 13, 2021
•From Google
My story starts off like most when you buy an older house. My wood shingle siding was pretty much cracking, peeling, and in horrible shape from the weather beatdown over the years. It was time for some vinyl siding with a touch of stone work to add character. I personally was a little obsessive about hiring the best contractor for the job. I had 5 quotes and James (owner of First Choice Renovations. Inc) shined above the rest. Personality, price quote, start date/completion date (5 months ahead of everyone else), and his promise to me that he would treat this home like it was his own. James not only delivered, he exceeded all my expectations. His team worked diligently through the weather conditions and went above and beyond. They even cleaned up another contractors left over mess from when I get a new roof installed. I knew my house was going to look good when they finished but my goodness, it was beyond what my mind could conjure. It looks like I just built a new home. I can't stop thanking James and his team for surpassing my vision and expectations in every way. I was just a person wanting a better look for his home and your suggestions and experience with what you thought would look good and what I should stay away from was greatly appreciated. You was not afraid to steer me away from bad quality or troublesome material. Honesty, trustworthiness,
and integrity is everything to me and you delivered. You have a customer for life!
Arber Emerllahu
Sep 13, 2022
•From Google
James Edwards and his team did a great job in repairing my old siding and doors. I had received approximately 10 quotes for a year before I pulled the trigger. I chose to go with James for the following reasons: he was very accommodating, met me at my time and even waited for me due to getting out of work later than expected. He was knowledgeable. 20+ years in the industry. He was polite and respectful towards myself and family. His price was reasonable for the services I obtained (Siding tear off, new vinyl siding, new gutters, 2 door installations, front entry and garage). His willingness to take on the job and get it done was something I appreciated bc it shows he is determined to get work done and in the right way. The final result was greater then expected. It was fine work. Elegant. Clean. All spots I verified were above and beyond. Put on the additional lights I got. Everything everything was just phenomenal. The team came in and finished the job in 5 days. House is about 1700sq ft. Overall, I’d recommend giving him a call if you have any work. At least get to know him a little, and see if works for you. For me, I’d choose him and his team 10/10 times. Great work James, thanks for your honest and fair work. Best of luck to you and your team for future projects. I couldn’t have had a better contractor to do my projects. Thank you! God Bless!
German Lopez
Apr 16, 2024
•From Google
The experience with First Choice Renovations was wonderful. From the moment that James introduced himself, I knew this was a contractor with vast knowledge, experience, and attention to detail. He took the time to listen to our needs and present us with a doable proposal. Sometimes, we all get taken by the size of the company or a brand /name. While this is a small to medium company, the quality of the work and attention to detail is better than many bigger companies in our area. Another factor that weighted heavy to give this company a go was that it was a family business. I also enjoyed that I got to know the crew, and they were always the same guys. James and his crew were approachable and were always sharing information on the process and answering my questions. I will recommend James his sons and the company to anyone who is looking for a company that does quality work at an affordable price without losing the customization look and touch. My family and I are statict with the result and we recommended to all our neighbors and people that ask us. Three to four weeks after completion, our house kept that house that everyone slowed down to look at, and everyone complemented. Thank you, First Choice Renovations.
Is this your business?
This business hasn't been claimed yet. Claim it to manage your listing.