
Overview
Serves New Berlin, WI
Business hours
SunClosedMon8:00 am - 6:00 pmTue8:00 am - 6:00 pmWed8:00 am - 6:00 pmThu8:00 am - 6:00 pmFri8:00 am - 6:00 pmSat9:00 am - 2:00 pm
Payment methods
This pro accepts payments via Cash, Check, Credit card, and Debit card.
Services offered
Contact
+14142265619
16920 W Cleveland Ave, New Berlin, WI 53151
Reviews
4.0
126 reviews
5
4
3
2
1
Dawn M
Jun 19, 2024
•From Google
Added 6/2 - Wish I could take out the one star. Still dealing with these horrible people at Guardian. Told me the way to fix this was to re-side the house because it was a manufacturer defect for the coating. The kicker to this is they want me to pay an additional $18,000 to what I already paid for the coating to bring the total to reside my moderate house to almost $38,000!! Why am I paying for a manufacturer defect. They think I am going away and that is not going to happen! No responses from Andy, ask to speak to owner, no response, call or anything. Filed a complaint with the BBB. Absolutely ridiculous making a customer pay for a manufacturer defect to make some of your money back.
Added 3/26/24 - here we are another spring, another year after this whole project started and now the paint is two tone in the front as well as looks like it is dripping (which I complained about in Oct/Nov when they decided to repaint when I told them not too due to weather) and the paint is bubbling, which is what happened last year. Why can't this company get it right? I have had them out to my house to fix so many times i cannot count. They do nothing like they say they will nor do they care what the customer is asking. I was told the siding being fixed (AGAIN) will be all one piece, but nope they still did it in pieces which makes it look horrible. I told them I didn't want a six inch piece of siding with a gap, again, NOPE they did not care. Worst company I have dealt with. I emailed the production manager Patti last year and she has ignored my emails. I hope now I can talk to a higher up manger/owner that will actually respond and rectify this as it should be.
I have done many renovations on my house over the last year and this was by far the worst experience I have had. I had siding replacement done and siding painting. I have had to continually follow up with them to check the status. I was lied to. They told me that production stated it would be ready in two weeks. I call a month later (because I didn't hear anything from anyone) and I was told then, they needed to reach out to production and guess what, it was another two weeks. They really didn't talk to production the first time. The work done by the contractor they used had to have them come out three times to fix things. They got paint on my brand new windows and screens, missed many spots, etc etc etc. The manager of the contractor was very pushy wanting me to OK the job to collect the money, when I said no, he got unprofessional. Guardian employees ended up fixing it, which I did appreciate. I let others know at Guardian of my experience and not one call by management or anything to check to understand what happened nor provide any discount for the inconvenience. Not recommend them at all. The only reason I am giving two stars is the professionalism of the salesman.
Adding to this review, because now SIX MONTHS later, the business finally decides to respond to my review. So if something didn't go wrong and had to come back out to fix, i would never hear a response? Never heard a beep from them after complaining last year. While I appreciate now they are fixing the paint peeling and bubbling as well as loose siding replacements, the process to do this was ridiculous. All I asked was for communication. Again, that was lacking. I had to call many times for follow up. Started this end of May and finally now in mid August, it is getting done (the one worker they have doing this (i was told it was a team) is awesome and very nice). This company really needs to work on communication. Once they get your money, you never hear from them unless you follow up. I had to get a manager involved to get some communication and even that sometimes didn't go a long way. Hopefully the repaint and siding fix will hold up, otherwise, it seems I will need to take more drastic measures.
Jerry S
Dec 8, 2022
•From Google
Thank you, Thank you, Thank you….(Patrick Fay, Theresa, Patti, Josh, and Tommy) Guardian Roofing in New Berlin, WI. You made our cruise to Alaska possible. Let me explain.
We had a nagging roof leak in our Familyroom which was supposedly fixed by other roofers. Yes, I said roofers. It was not, however, which was evident when we opened up the drywall. Over the past 3-4 years, no roofer was able to find the source. We were planning to go on our first cruise since the Covid shutdown with a committed late August 2022 departure.
Our first contact with Guardian was Patrick Fay a Certified Home Advisor in sales who came out July 22, 2022 to assess our situation. After giving our cedar shake roof a thorough inspection, he confidently assured us of our roof’s integrity and said he had found the source of our leak. We heard that before from other companies including the need to replace the entire roof, so I was very skeptical.
I then turned to the reviews on Guardian. There were lots of glowing 5* Star reviews. I told Patrick that we could not get a house sitter to take care of our two cats while we were on the cruise unless the roof leak was fixed. At the time we needed pots to catch the water during a hard rain which was also attacking a built in floor to ceiling bookcase.
Patrick said with all their work backlog and material supply shortages, getting the roof repaired prior to our cruise would be difficult, but he would try. The contract was then signed with a conditional pending stipulation to have all work completed before August 25th, less that 4 weeks away. Patrick came out and layed a tarp to stop the leak which had to be redone after a wind storm proved to much for the first try. “No Problem I will redo it” he said, which he did without complaining the next day.
Next Teresa (Customer Agent) and Patti (Accounting) called me repeatedly to keep me advised of the status of the project and to work out the financial details. Thank you ladies for keeping in such close contact. They told me that the work would commence one week prior to August 25th. As promised by them on August 17th, the work was started by Tommy and Josh.
They were both engagingly communicative, keeping me advised all through the process including taking before and after photos of the job. I was impressed by their professionalism and customer oriented nature, including the nightly clean up which was thorough. They completed the job in 3 days which included having to replace some additional plywood sheathing they unexpectedly found after removing the old shake.
As weather would have it, the very next day, the repair got it ultimate test a 2in/hr downpour. There was standing water in our backyard and on our patio and deck. The roof, however, had absolutely no leaking.
As we had planned and committed to our cruise to Alaska was “Good to Go”.
I would give the Guardian Team and Company 10* Stars if I could.
Thank you once again…Patrick, Pattie, Theresa, Josh, and Tommi. I hope, Theresa, that you and others enjoy the one of a kind photos of the grizzly bears and hump back whales.
Sandra Woolweber
Sep 17, 2023
•From Google
My project:
I was in need of a complete roof tear-off and a new roof installation on both my home and garage roofs. I found their company via the Valpak Coupons. I reviewed this company on line and with the BBB. This is a 5 star company!
Patrick Fay from Guardian Home Improvements came out to my home for a roof inspection and quote estimate. He was on time and very polite. He was very helpful by taking pictures of my current roofs and chimney area. He explained the problem areas he noted on the roof and chimney area. Patrick even came back to my home with shingle samples and provided me help picking out just the right shingle for my home. Patrick was not pushy, very honest, thorough and knowledgeable with the information he provided to all of my questions. Patrick has displayed much compassion to my current situation. He followed up with me via phone, text and email from start to finish!
Installation Day:
The company had a delay on another job so I was notified that my home roofing installation would occur the next day. The crew started at 7 am and finished at 6:30 pm. The crew worked very hard and as a skilled team all day long. They were very careful and particular with their work. They provided quality work! The clean up was very complete on my property when they were done! They went above and beyond throughout the entire day!
I do have to note:
They initially had delivered the wrong color shingles by mistake. I had notified Patrick and he quickly corrected the situation for me. While waiting for the new shingle delivery the crew was able to keep the roofing project moving along.
Even during the installation when I had questions I had sent Patrick pictures of my questions and Patrick responded quickly to ease my anxiety and clarify the installation process. He had followed up with me after the installation and came to my home for a final examination of the work provided. He also had provided more pictures of the completed roof!
Patrick's communication style is very special! He cares about the customer's he serves. He displays that he truly respects and values the company he works for and wants each homeowner to receive quality work at a fair price! So thank you Patrick from the bottom of my heart! I truly appreciate you and your company!
Guardian Home Improvement is lucky to have Patrick working for them! He is the first person that the customer meets and he does a fantastic job! Take care and God Bless!
Emily Broback
Jun 19, 2024
•From Google
*EDIT* Here we are, 2 years later and still dealing with this terrible company. After many phone calls, they came last fall to "fix" the terrible caulk and the pieces that were falling off. They attempted to grind off the caulk and in the process, damaged the trim even more. They then attempted to cover these scratches by smearing caulk over them. Now it looks worse, which I didn't realize was possible. When My husband and I went to inspect the "fixes", we were told by Josh that his boss is pissed off by my google review and if I would agree to take it down, they would power wash my siding for free. WOW!! What a deal. Not. I told him that I won't be taking it down and I just want my trim fixed. So, after many phone calls over the winter, I was told they would be there in March to fix everything. Nope. They haven't shown up. I have called and left many messages since and received no response. They have also blocked me on Facebook after I left a negative review there. So, it looks like I will be contacting a lawyer and getting my money back. I have also filed a report with the BBB.
We used Guardian to have our wood trim wrapped in aluminum.
Darlene, that gave us the estimate was so friendly and helpful. Theresa from the office called and said she would call me every other week with an update.
After the contract was signed and they had half of the payment in their pockets, all communications ceased. I called several times a week and left a message requesting a call back. I only received one when I threatened to call a lawyer.
At this point it had been almost 5 months since I paid them almost $4000.
Nick and Bobby, that handled most of our installation were AMAZING! Nick was in constant communication during the entire project. They were professional, friendly, and great at their jobs!
Nick, Bobby, and Darlene would earned Guardian 5 stars.
However, communication from the office is very lacking.
*EDIT*In October (2 months after they completed the project) I noticed that one of the vents had been put on upside down and some of the trim was coming off and the majority of the caulk looks awful so I contacted them again since they have a guarantee. Again, I had to leave multiple messages before hearing back from anyone. I was told someone would be out the following week. Nothing. After multiple email exchanges with Tracy, I was told they would be out on December 30th. I stayed home all day and no one showed.
I understand that everyone is short staffed right now but all they really needed to do was give me a quick call or shoot me an email saying as much and that they were trying to get us on the schedule ASAP. Going completely silent and ignoring clients is not the way to get repeat customers.
I have lost all confidence in Guardian. There were multiple people in our neighborhood that were going to use them for the same service and for new roofs, gutters, and siding but they have now gone elsewhere.
Jeni Gentil
Sep 17, 2023
•From Google
I don’t recommend using Guardian. I met with Bobby on 4/26/22 and was looking to get a quote for a roof repair related to an insurance claim as my roof was leaking into three rooms. I also required aluminum siding repairs due to the numerous dings, dents, tears, etc. At this point I had received 5 quotes for the roof and Bobby informed me that he could have the project done in 4-6 weeks. As this was quicker than the other contractors I decided to go with Guardian that day. Theresa the account manager was great to start. She told me she would call every other week with an update. It was great for the month of May, however the communication fell through in June when the project was supposed to be completed. In June, they were still waiting on materials. July, no calls. I had to reach out to them and again asked why it was taking so long as I have roof leaks and was informed that they were just waiting for other projects to be completed, but had no idea when those would be completed as they were short staffed. I finally had to engage one of the other contractors for my roof as I continued to receive damage to my home each time it rained and they completed it in a week. August, still no calls until 8/31 when they said they would be there the next day. As the roof was already done I told them the quote would need to be redone now. Bobby called on 9/1/22 and said he wished someone had told him about the roof leaks even though this was known at the time I signed the contract. He was willing to work with me as I still wanted to have the siding repaired. Each time an appointment was scheduled to revisit the quote, there was some other issue that was more important or they didn’t call or show at all for the appointment scheduled. The quotes that were given to me were for less repairs than originally agreed and for more money than originally agreed to. They also refused to itemize the quote when asked due to the smaller scope and never even looked at the house again to produce the revised quote. As of 10/3/22, no work has been performed and I have received no contact from Guardian despite sending a complaint letter directly to them and filing a complaint with the BBB. I am very disappointed in the way this business relationship has been handled and will not be recommending Guardian to anyone else.
Is this your business?
This business hasn't been claimed yet. Claim it to manage your listing.