
Overview
Serves Milford, OH
3 employees
Business hours
SunClosedMon8:00 am - 6:00 pmTue8:00 am - 6:00 pmWed8:00 am - 6:00 pmThu8:00 am - 6:00 pmFri8:00 am - 6:00 pmSat9:00 am - 2:00 pm
Payment methods
This pro accepts payments via Cash, Check, Credit card, and Debit card.
Services offered
Contact
shollon@potterhillhomes.com
+15132484428
1252 State Route 28, Milford, OH 45150
Reviews
1.0
13 reviews
5
4
3
2
1
Brian and Julie Robinson
Oct 28, 2018
•From Google
My wife and I entered into a contract with Potterhill Homes last fall to build a home on our own lot, a process we had never experienced. Our realtor recommended Potterhill as an experienced builder that would be helpful in guiding us through the process. From the start they communicated that securing a bid for a septic system would be something we would need to do on our own. Unfortunately, they did not ensure we secured the necessary steps prior to entering into a contract. The process was more complicated than expected. We completed all of the steps to move the planning of the home forward purchased a lot, paid an additional $10,000 toward the home in addition to the first $1,000.00, completed the financing for the construction loan, completed the selection process, etc.. However, we discovered that the location initially considered during the contract phase of the home, and used to determine cost was not buildable because the home would be placed in the location of the acceptable soil for septic.
The acceptable location determined would place the home significantly farther back on the lot causing additional cost of approximately $15,000.00 and placing the home in an undesirable location on the side of a hill (verified verbally in person by the builder contact). To mitigate this situation, we had to pursue additional soil testing (which we paid to conduct) causing delays. In addition, we learned that the estimate provided to us by the builder to budget for our initial contract was likely under-estimated by at least $10,000.00 (also verified verbally by the builder). This caused delays. At the end of January 2018, I was asked if we had a location. I replied that we still needed to gather additional information but that the soil testing had indicated that we would likely be able to move the initial plot forward slightly from where we had previously determined but that I needed to gather additional information to understand difference in budget from our initial agreement.
It was at that time I was informed that we had exceeded the 90 day contract window and “if we wanted to continue to build” it would cost approximately $17,000.00 more than originally contracted and that the price would go up again if we did not begin within 60 days. My realtor then communicated that, given the unforeseeable increase, we no longer would like to pursue the build and requested steps for returning our deposit. It was at that time we were told that we would not receive any portion of our deposit back. They proceeded to cancel my construction loan with the bank, without my direct consent, and determined we were in breach of contract. While the contract does have a 90 day clause, no actual work had taken place on site (no clearing of land, no breaking of ground, no staking of lines, etc..).
The contract does not indicate how much the cost could increase other than to state it is to reflect increases in construction costs. In addition, other sales materials and pre-construction agreements indicate that steps should not proceed until necessary septic permits and bids are in place prior to entering into the process. This is likely something I should have reviewed early, but also something an experienced builder may have honored to protect the buyer from this situation. When asking for a return of the deposit, the builder listed what they determined to be actual costs invested in the project despite not actually initiating the build on site in any capacity. These costs, by their estimates (which I believe to be high) were less than $5,000.00. The remaining money they stated they were entitled to keep as well. Given that the build did not begin in any capacity, and the rather arbitrary price increase required to continue, we believe that a large portion of the $11,000.00 should be returned. There are multiple other concerns/complaints that have not been outlined in this description, but the above is an outline of the most pertinent facts
Bret P
Oct 28, 2019
•From Google
We went to Potter hill Homes when we were discussing building a home. The sales rep was very friendly and provided us a lot of information, but after talking with PHH I felt like they were trying to manipulate us and lying to us to get a sale.
For example, when we first reached out the lot they had listed was a set price and the sales rep confirmed this price with us and schedule an appointment. Once we went and met in person she informed us that the price was raising 20,000 dollars because the missed updating the prices on the lot by three times. She said they would work with us to get the price knocked back down, help us get a loan through a partner bank, help us get a partial finished basement and other nice amentitites. The downfall about all of that was most of that was part of their original offer.
We decided to listen regardless and talk about things we would like in the house. The base price of the house would include level one of their furnishings which is basic. She said go ahead and look around and put a wish list of what you would like. I started asking questions about how much certain things would cost and she said she didn't know but it didn't matter because it was our wish list and we could take it off. I wanted to know, because I like to budget and have my costs together upfront. We decided to just go ahead and get a list together. It ended up being 40 thousand on top of the initial base cost of the house in addition to the 20 thousand they already added.
She said since we started talking to her a couple weeks before the prices changed she would get the PHH to get that price for us. After various correspondence she said they could do it because they missed updating it on their side three times and the cost of materials went up alot. I don't disagree with their integrity or resources, but I looked at the track record of the costs of lumber and other materials at this time and it was evident that they were not much different in the time period she mentioned, but I didn't want to argue.
We ended up letting them know that we would go with the house if they would let us have the original price, but they weren't willing to budge. Not even 1 dollar. I wrote a very informative letter explaining the benefits for them to sell the last remaining lot to us. A few key points were they wouldn't have to worry about it any longer and they could focus on their main locations. The lot is limited and people can't expand the garage, a sunroom, and are only limited to a couple of floor plans. Plus they wouldn't have to worry about the taxes and etc. Moving forward. After I sent the letter she responded back and took my note as complaining and said well maybe potterhill homes isn't for you. I was highly disappointed with her comments since I was trying to be Immformative and get the price they originally had listed.
After that I thanked her for her time and sent her a 10 dollar Starbucks gift card and never heard from her again. 5 months later we purchased a home in the same neighborhood 1 street away and the lot we were looking at is still vacant 19 months later from our original communication.
I really wish them the best and their homes are beautiful, but I'm turned off by the way they handled business with us.
Ian Byrne
Oct 28, 2020
•From Google
This review is based on buying a 3 yr old build Potterhill Home. We bought our house in the Pond Creek Sub just outside of Alexandria, KY. Our house is rare as it was just built on a slab. I have a 3 Star not because of how we bought it, but how we’re seeing the house after it’s had some time to settle and be broken in. We had our house inspected prior to being bought by a respected inspector. The drywall nails are popping out all over the place! It’s not just in one section of the house, it’s in every room. The door are starting to not close all the way in some rooms/halls. Some of the wiring was put in wrong as some of our switches aren’t even for the intended appliance or room. One switch stops the switch down stairs from even turning on! Our slab already has a good sized crack in it we noticed when we re did our carpet last year.
I will say, we’re surrounded by Maronda Houses and I’ve heard more complaints on their houses than I do mine. We love our house and we are going to stay here for as long as we can. Just wish we could of had these issues done correctly prior to the house even being built.
Justin O'Donnell
Oct 28, 2019
•From Google
Unfortunately, this builder does not - and will not - stand behind their product. A laundry list of issues were outstanding to be fixed on my home and were documented at the time of closing, in November 2017. To date, the vast majority of these have not been addressed.
Approximately 5 months ago, my basement was completely flooded due to improper installation of the basement windows. The foundation was not sealed around the window frames, leaving holes where water could run in. Additionally, the windows did not even fit the actual frames themselves, and instead of being mounted via the two pre-drilled holes on each side, were screwed in via the center of each side of the frame, causing both to warp out of shape.
I lost over $1,000 worth of items due to the water intrusion, and Potterhill refuses to reimburse these losses, despite their own warranty agent and window company confirming the installation being botched in multiple ways.
Back when we were planning our home in 2017, the sales team was extremely responsive, and easy to work with, right up until the day they got our deposit. Since then, it has been an absolute nightmare attempting to get anything repaired.
I cannot in good conscience recommend this builder based on my experience from the start of the build process onward.
Samuel Goodwin
Oct 28, 2018
•From Google
My experience with Potterhill homes, building our home was priceless,. We were always informed of each stage we transition to. Joe our superintendent at that time was just awsome, he ensured all was done right. When questions came up Potterhill was right on it with a quick callback from one of their Reps. I have spoke highly of Potterhill to everyone who have came into contact with me about our home. If one look at the craftsmanship, of our home it truly stands out from the rest in our community .
Is this your business?
This business hasn't been claimed yet. Claim it to manage your listing.