Superior Fence & Rail

Superior Fence & Rail

Overview

Serves Middleton, WI

Business hours

SunClosedMon8:00 am - 6:00 pmTue8:00 am - 6:00 pmWed8:00 am - 6:00 pmThu8:00 am - 6:00 pmFri8:00 am - 6:00 pmSat9:00 am - 2:00 pm

Payment methods

This pro accepts payments via Cash, Check, Credit card, and Debit card.

Services offered
Contact

+16084402889

1600 N High Point Rd Suite 140, Middleton, WI 53562

Reviews
4.0

1339 reviews

5

4

3

2

1

B Terp

Oct 27, 2024

•From Google
Have to wonder how this trashy company could get 4.9 stars after personally dealing with their lack of accountability, respect and professionalism. Only employee worth talking to was Natalie, the receptionist who unfortunately couldn’t do anything more than what she had. Then there’s Zach, the supposed project manager that can’t even manage himself, let alone the crew of grown man children they hired. Then we have Matt, the supposed owner/operator of the Kalamazoo location that NEVER BOTHERED to return my call. Allow me to paint you a picture imagine getting ready to leave for work and your next door neighbor has a crew tearing down an old wooden perimeter fence to have a new, god ugly, bright white vinyl piece of crap replace it. Supposedly a one day job according to the information provided to my neighbor. So like a good neighbor, you move your vehicles out of the way, clear your side of the fence, create a little dog corral to keep your pets away from the hazards and the crew. You even establish contact with them letting them know they are welcome to be on your property. Then, while you are away from home tending to your regular responsibilities, your significant other is constantly contacting you regarding the absolute dismay that has become their job site. Imagine being told that your significant other was disrespected and scoffed at when they ask the crew nicely to run a magnet through the driveway next to fence that was demolished carelessly. They act like they had never heard of a rolling magnet designed to pick up nails and staples from work sites. Oh wait, they are only 12 years old.. or at least that is how they act and appear. Imagine coming home at 6 pm to see all the chopped up ivy that riddled the old fence strewn across your property. As you begin to take a closer look, the day care crew is scurrying to leave site. Then while talking to your neighbor about the horrible mess that was left on both sides of the UNFINISHED fence with 2 gaps that are anywhere from 5-10 feet open, one of the children that calls himself a Superior Fence Man was left behind to cowardly inform my neighbor that they will be back next week to finish, intended on leaving the fence open. Gratefully, my neighbor and I are of the same understanding that this behavior, craftsmanship and professionalism is just unacceptable, especially since they have a couple of toddlers and we have a couple of dogs. Imagine spending the next 2 hours picking up nails, staples, wooden shards and chunks… and any other unearthed crap that was tossed on your property, not including the damn IVY that is everywhere. Now, imagine that same kid coming back the next day to put in a temporary chain link barrier and when you ask him to ask his boss Zach to call you and ask him to clean up after themselves, this kid who is a fraction of your age with a fraction of your life experience responds by laughing at you when you turn your back after his sidekick worker tries to argue that he was not there the day before. Now imagine confronting the kid that just laughed at you by reminding him/them that they are on camera and have been the entire time including when they played with my neighbors kids toys, tossing balls around to each other and shooting nerf darts at each other. After reminding them that you would definitely be in contact with their employers, you have to leave for work leaving them unattended and unsupervised. Another day hearing from your spouse about everything new that is being found in your yard because the kids got upset for getting cut into. Cigarette butts, new chunks of OSB? that came out of nowhere and oh yeah, the flower garden that once was beautiful completely trampled with no regard to what was happening. Including the bleeding heart bush I bought my wife for our anniversary years ago… wasted. So, you call twice a reach Natalie the receptionist without a return response from supposed owner Matt. All the evidence doesn’t mean a thing… because you aren’t writing the checks. Superior Fence and Rail… because you will get railed.

Molly Wells

Nov 10, 2022

•From Google
We chose to work with Superior Fence and Rail because the estimator said it would take 4 weeks from the day of his visit to install our fence. He said the partnership with Home Depot meant Superior always had items in stock. He assured us our choice of a split rail fence with welded wire was a basic, uncomplicated fence. On 8/30/21 Stacey texted me to say we could install on 9/7/21. Almost immediately, she corrected herself saying she didn't know when the wire would be in stock. I contacted her multiple times to follow up and she did not respond until 9/9 to put us on the schedule for 10/6-10/7/21. On 9/27 Stacey informed me Superior was not able to find the end rail posts needed for our fence. She told me she was "sure I had been told our fence was a special order" fence (contradicting the original estimator). She told me there was no estimated date for when our fence would be installed. We had already paid the 50% deposit. I spoke with Stacey at length about my disbelief that she was telling me this news a week before install - to which, Stacey eventually hung up on me. I called back to ask for the manager's number - Mike. I expressed that I was unhappy with her customer service and the indefinite delay and she said "good luck" trying to get a discount from Mike. I reached out to Stacey multiple times because I was able to find the end posts in stock at different locations, but she did not respond. On 9/28 Stacey informed me she found the material and our fence could be installed on 10/16. The 10/16 Saturday installation day arrived and we received no confirmation call ahead of time. I had to call Stacey (waking her up at 830am) in the morning to see when/if the crew was arriving. Later in the afternoon it became clear there was not near enough material to complete the job - the crew had about 50-65% of what they needed. A crew member called Stacey on speakerphone to inform her of the situation. They asked if she wanted to speak with the customer and she emphatically said "No no no! I'll text them on Monday." Monday we called the owner Mike to speak about when our fence would be finished and he never returned our phone call. We spoke with Stacey who said she would personally come out for our final installation (now 10/23) to make sure our fence was the way we wanted, although she never showed up. We had a number of issues with how the fence was installed as the crew ended up working in the dark. The biggest issue was the welded wire installation. It has always been listed on our contract to leave a gap at the bottom of the wire. However, when the crew installed the wire, they installed it all the way to the ground. The wire also stuck up beyond the top rail. When confronted, Stacey said they never had the option to order a different size wire. That information should have been communicated to us from day one. As installed, we had sharp, jagged wire at the top and bottom of the fence because they had to cut the wire. See photos. A crew member called Stacey to ask about cutting the wire and we heard her on speaker phone say "Just do it, I told them we would, just do it so that you never have to come back to this house EVER AGAIN." That emphasis was hers, not mine. We are beyond disappointed with the customer service we've received along the way for this project. We've been strung along and clearly Stacey's attitude towards us has impacted how she conducted the business of our job - not ordering enough material, not communicating about the wire, and more. Our fence finally has been repaired so it is no longer dangerous as of May 2022. We attempted to call/email/text the owner, Stacey, the owners in Jacksonville and no one returned our call. It is in the contract that faulty worksmanship will be covered by the company. It was only when we threatened legal action because of the dangerous fence we have on our property they finally sent out someone to "repair" it. The customer service of this company is atrocious. Take your business elsewhere.

Joe Perino

Jun 13, 2024

•From Google
This review is a little delayed but well deserved. Superior Fence was contracted to replace an existing wood fence. The project was planned for the winter months, but delays with obtaining a survey and permit, no fault of Superior Fence, delayed the installation until the Spring. Superior Fence handled the entire process (except the boundary survey), including obtaining the installation permit from the town, especially necessary since we have an in-ground pool and want to ensure the fence meets the latest requirements. Their office provided regular communication throughout the process, which included permitting delays because the survey was delayed and the town was rebuilding their offices, and other scheduling issues. They worked to accommodate my hectic schedule as much as possible. My primary office contact was Masum Amin, and she was absolutely terrific to work with. The installation of the new wood fence included some difficulties to overcome, with some drainage concerns, a sloped grade, two sheds and neighbor's fencing to work around, existing landscaping along the fence line, ground for the electric service, and one non-standard gate width along with a double service gate. Again, they were retrofitting a new fence to replace an existing one. The installation started on April 11. Ismael and his entire crew, especially Robert, were absolutely terrific. They removed the old fence and fence posts, no easy task, and replaced the exisiting posts despite some poor weather, including oversized posts for the gates. The next day the weather was really bad, but the crew came in the afternoon after a break in the weather to close in my neighbor's yard for his dog, and remove some remaining dirt and debris Thank you also to John Carlevaro, operations coordinator. The installed fencing follows the grade perfectly. They made cuts and adjustments to accommodate a large magnolia tree and drainage piping. The gates are aligned and open and close perfectly. The retrofit was not easy and not exact to the old fence but solutions were found for all of those little things that will inevitably come up. There were a lot of details and issues that Robert and his helper worked with me to solve and resolve on the fly. A few visits were required after the initial install to address some minor issues with the fence in the front yard where it meets my neighbor's fence, and the initial permit inspection, which was scheduled by their office. All open issues were addressed, and a couple weeks after the installation started, it was approved by the township building inspector. The original salesperson and operations manager, Mark McCloskey, came to inspect the installation and even personally address some minor issues. Communication throughout the entire process was outstanding, and they did everything they could to ensure we were satisfied with the installation. I am extremely pleased to have chosen Superior Fence to handle this project. The entire team, from sales to the office to the onsite crews, were fantastic to work with and ultimately they did a great job.

Leighann Beckett

Nov 10, 2019

•From Google
Out of all the good reviews for Superior Fence of Lake County, I’m left wondering how our experience with this the company has been so terrible. First and foremost the lack of communication with the office staff has been the worst I’ve probably ever dealt with. Installation took nearly 2 months from the date our contract was signed & submitted. Our HOA required approval & responded the same day the application was submitted, stating they needed the fence drawn out on the survey & resubmitted. I immediately responded & asked Superior’s office manager if this was something we needed to do.. she said “no, we will take care of this.” 2 weeks later I followed up with my HOA & they still had not received the revised application. Called Superior & the office manager said we were still waiting on the HOA when in fact it was their office causing the delay because they never resubmitted the survey with the plans as they said they were going to do. Next, we had some rather large & expensive plants near the property line. I was told to request Debbie come out & mark off for us where the fence would be going so that we could be sure to remove the needed brush prior to installation. I requested Debbie give me a heads up when she was coming so I could meet her as I had some questions.. instead she showed up unannounced when no one was home & places several flags (which ended up being off by 3 feet). She never once followed up or even let me know she came by & placed the flags. I called her a couple times & never received a call back. Our contract shows the fence going back 7 feet on both sides of the house yet one side is attached at the very back of the house. So I’m paying for 7 feet or fence that was never installed? I’ve asked the office to contact me to resolve (after Debbie came & placed the flags & before installation) never heard back from the office manager as I was promised. Lastly, the installers drilled a superior fence sign into the front of the fence, which I am very dissatisfied with. This was not on the estimate & nor was I ever asked if I wanted their sign drilled into my brand new vinyl panels. Our fence was a nearly 300 feet & we paid GOOD money for it. I went with superior based on reviews & a referral from an acquaintance. (We had a total of 3 estimates, one of which was several hundred dollars cheaper than Superior) Debbie was initially great & my husband said he felt Superior was the best choice but now I wish we hadn’t. The day of installation I called the morning of because I wanted to be there when the installers arrived & I was told they would be there between 10-11 so I left work to come meet with them. Sat home till 11:30.. they never showed until sometime after noon. (Not a huge deal, I understand things happen, but just to add to the list of disappointment) Our fence was finished in 3 days, which was expected due to the size of yard & all the recent rain but tomorrow will be a week since day 1 of installation & I’ve not received one call to follow up, never did any final walk throughs or inspections & here I am expressing my concerns on the web. While for the most part the fence is beautiful (my only reason for giving 2 stars) I’m extremely disappointed & would not recommend this office to anyone. I have reached out via email, being that is usually the only way I can get a hold of anyone at Superior, so I hope someone will do their diligence & follow up to correct the issues so that we do not need to take further action.

Michael Hugo

Jun 22, 2024

•From Google
I recently had Superior Fence Company install a fence in my yard. It entailed taking down a 90 foot section of an old shadow box fence I had installed 32 years ago, and installing a cedar solid wall fence in its place. The work was complex since they had to core several holes in my 6 inch thick concrete driveway to install the metal posts. It was arduous work for the installers, Daniel and Roldolfo on a hot May day. Both of the men were friendly and professional. My driveway and yard was left spotless at the end of the installation--they cleaned up everything, including the messy 90 feet of old fence, as well as the dirt dislodged for post holes. Daniel, who I understand has 30 years of work in the fence business was a master at his work. On the few occasions they needed to consult me, they came over and sorted through their question with me. I am entirely happy with the work and would recommend Superior to anyone considering installing a fence. I must also acknowledge the salesperson, Eric Dorsey, who worked closely with me in making the right choice of fence. I actually met him in a Jewel parking lot 8 months ago after some small talk about the weather. I took his card and in April, gave him a call, reminding him about our chance encounter months before. We set up an appointment for him to come by, and he was here right on time, giving me serious professional advice about the job I wanted. He actually steered me in a different direction than what I thought I wanted to do initially, and for that I am grateful. He was prompt in communication with me via text, never letting a text go more than half a day before he responded. He also showed up on the day of the job, twice to check in with me and his crew. In the end, I was quite pleased with the job and highly recommend them. I had actually had two other fence companies popular in my area come by (one actually didn't even respond to my request) and I was sorely disappointed with them. So for the three men whom I worked with, Eric, Daniel and Roldolfo I offer kudos. Also I will give a shout out to the business person I talked with, Rosalinda, who helped me over the phone a couple times. Having installed fences early in my life, I know first hand how difficult this work is, and how much skill it takes to do it properly. Superior did a superior job. I do hope the company recognizes the quality of their workers and hopefully compensates them appropriately for their diligent and challenging work. Michael Hugo
Is this your business?

This business hasn't been claimed yet. Claim it to manage your listing.